Crogan's Montclair

10/27/09

This place has really turned it around!!

by ryanjet99 at Citysearch

I used to come here a long while back, but haven't been for years. When my friend asked me to join her here I jumped at the chance. This place has really turned it around from what I remember. The food was amazing, our waiter was great, and we had a wonderful time. I'm not sure why I stopped coming here, but I know I'll be coming back!

• Pros: Great food, location, and service.
• Cons: Parking isn't the best.

12/12/08

Salmon caused bad stomach ache/nausea/dizziness & No apologies from manager or chef!

by glowskid at Citysearch

12/5 a friend and I ate salmon entrees, two different ones. That night, I became ill with a bad stomach ache, nausea, and dizziness. Initially, I thought I was coming down with something, but after eating leftovers the following day, I experienced the same symptoms. I contacted my friend and found that she had the same experience! So, it was definitely the salmon! To date (12/12) manager and chef have not offered an apology to me! Food is not fresh, and the service is obviously awful.

01/05/08

3 1/12 stars?????

by lynxeye99 at Citysearch

I have had mixed experiences here. Lunch has been good. However at night, this service takes and major nose dive. Its kind of like going to pizza hut and being served on by Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie. There seems to be little interest in providing quality dining experience or good food. The bartender essentially ignored us (even though she glanced at us from time to time) because she was too caught up in a personal conversation with another staff member. Amazingly poor service.

• Pros: its the only bar in the area that has a TV with sports
• Cons: Service, Food, Prices